Fluids
Posted under Miscellanea at .
I had this thought about gender-fluidity, which on consideration may illuminate the subject of gender more broadly.
Having met people who assert a variety of non-binary gender identities over the years, I’ve always been a little puzzled by the concept of fluidity, compared to gender as a reasonably constant thing. (In the absence of some major event requiring transition, though that’s more often a long-term mismatch rather than a specific event obvious to others.) I had no reason to disbelieve anyone, but I somehow didn’t get it.
I have considered that perhaps a very neutral position on the hypothetical feminine-to-masculine spectrum could produce a variable gender identity, if external influences could then overcome the neutral state. But that doesn’t clearly explain why there are people with fluid and people with consistently neutral identities. I also tend to think that masculinity-to-femininity as commonly practiced is not a single-dimensional spectrum, but rather a very approximate two-dimensional aggregate of characteristics which derive much of their imagined grouping from social influences anyway. However:
Perhaps We Flow
It occurred to me recently that another way of looking at it is that fluidity might be the norm. That is to say, that ordinary humans don’t necessarily have a real permanent sense of gender identity to begin with, rather than intermittent ones which are assumed and reified in between times. As someone once put it, ‘I don’t wake up every morning and immediately think oh-my-god-I’m-a-woman.’